A nonprofit publication of the Kentucky Center for Public Service Journalism

Kentucky Chamber releases ‘Leaky Bucket: 10 Years Later,’ cites major budget leaks consuming tax $$$

Kentucky continues to struggle to slow state spending in key areas that are diverting funds from investments in education, according to a new report from the Kentucky Chamber of Commerce.

The Leaky Bucket: 10 Years Later, released Tuesday, is an update of the Chamber’s original report that identified corrections, Medicaid and public employee benefits as major budget leaks that were consuming tax dollars at a rate that was growing faster than the overall state budget.

These leaks accounted for more than half of all growth in the budget from 2000 to 2010, with money being allocated to them at a much higher rate than for education.

Since the first Leaky Bucket was published, several bipartisan policies have been enacted in an effort to curb the disturbing spending trends and, for a while, it appeared that the policies might slow, if not stop, some of the leaking.

“Unfortunately, this has not been the case,” noted Chamber President and CEO Ashli Watts. “With the opioid epidemic plaguing our state and the resulting growth in the prison population, escalating costs associated with Medicaid, and continuing challenges with the pension systems, Kentucky is still struggling to fix the leaks.”

The latest update examined spending trends from fiscal year 2016 to fiscal year 2020 and found:

• Total General Fund spending grew 14.5%.

• Corrections spending increased by 15.9%.

• Medicaid spending grew 25.6%.

• Public employee health insurance grew by 5.5%, a notable improvement.

• Pension spending has doubled.

• K-12 education funding increased by 1.2%; spending on non-SEEK items has grown by 30.8%.

• Postsecondary education funding decreased by 6%.

The report concludes more revenue is required in addition to continued program reforms, representing a significant departure from the Chamber’s earlier Leaky Bucket reports.

“The Commonwealth cannot reform or cut its way out of current funding challenges without falling further behind in areas critical to our future,” the report noted. “We must ‘look beyond the bucket’ to generate additional revenue. Kentucky needs pro-business tax reform that improves the Commonwealth’s competitiveness while producing new net revenue to support education and develop a modern workforce.”

Click here to download the Leaky Bucket: 10 Years Later report.

Current spending trends

Kentucky Chamber of Commerce

Related Posts


  1. Steven Louis Frank says:

    Why would the Chamber of Commerce be favor of raising taxes before there is fundamental reform of the Medicaid and Pension systems??? Seems to me like the Chamber is suggesting that we just pour more water into a bucket with lots of holes in it. Maybe we should get a new bucket first???

    • Carrie Owens says:

      Steven, because the Chamber is full of liberals and non-profits. In the end it’s sad, but is funny how much of a contradiction Chambers have become.. they changed by-laws to allow non profits to join in order for the chamber executives and staff to make more money by growing the membership numbers and people paying more dues. But what happened thereafter was the for-profit members work all week and nights and don’t have time to attend events and participate as much, so it’s all non-profit socialists who have too much free time and those people taking over committee positions and staff positions and making their stances and policy decisions for more taxes, more government, more “free” stuff, trying to allow homeless camps, no guns, less pro business growth, etc. etc.
      They are literally the opposite now of what the Chambers were originally formed to do. The whole evolution deserves a segment on comedy central or SNL.
      Everyone in business knows it too.
      Just attend any of their events you’ll see them and their “guest speakers” all bash capitalism, true business growth, and especially pro-business policy, usually republican politicians both local, state, and national.

Leave a Comment